Related: Welcome to Shelbyville, Events, Immigration, Screenings
Related:
"Everybody's got to have somebody to look down on," Kris Kristofferson sang in "Jesus Was a Capricorn," and the proof may be in Kim Snyder's documentary Welcome to Shelbyville -- which airs May 24 on PBS' Independent Lens series, but has a local screening with director Snyder expected to attend at 3 p.m. Saturday at the downtown Nashville Public Library. (There is a reception at 2:30.) In her film, Snyder visits Shelbyville, Tenn., in the year leading up to the historic 2008 presidential election, when racial tensions across the country were already on edge. But in Bedford County, where illegal Hispanic workers at the local Tyson Foods plant began to be replaced by hundreds of Somali refugees, the combination of economic strain, job insecurity, anti-Muslim fear and culture clash sent shock waves along every possible ethnic fault line. Snyder talks to residents, refugees, and to reporter Brian Mosely, whose articles in the Shelbyville Times-Gazette provoked an open discussion of relations between the townspeople and the incoming immigrants. The result sometimes resembles a pot whose contents stubbornly refuse to melt, even as the heat rises. The screening is free and open to the public. JIM RIDLEY
Related:
A documentary on the rapid growth of the Somali refugee population in a small Tennessee town is getting its Louisville premiere tonight and will air next week on KET2.
The documentary, "Welcome to Shelbyville," charts the varied reactions, from hostile to hospitable, to the arrival of Somalis in the rural Tennessee community, which had already adjusted to an influx of Hispanics. Many of the Somalis arrived to work in a meat-packing plant, and the documentary showed the clash between the native-born residents, both black and white, over such issues as religion (Muslims had been rare in the Bible Belt town), race, mannerisms, culture and hygiene. A former mayor cites fears of everything from disease to terrorism, but the documentary seeks a hopeful angle on the possibilities of immigration across cultural chasms.
It will certainly be of interest to Kentuckians, giving the growing Somali populations in such areas as Louisville and, at least for a time, Mayfield. Nor is it the first compelling documentary on this subject. "The Letter," produced a few years back, talks about similar conflicts in Lewiston, Maine.
The documentary is being shown at 6 p.m. Thursday at NuLu Black Box, 812 Market St., according to film representatives. It's scheduled to run on KET2 on May 24 at 10 p.m.
More information at www.pbs.org/independentlens/welcome-to-shelbyville.
Related:
PR Newswire
WASHINGTON, May 17, 2011
Welcome to Shelbyville focuses on community relations in a small Tennessee town and will air nationwide on the PBS Series "Independent Lens" on May 24, 2011
Welcoming America affiliates, community groups and city officials across the country, are using local screenings as a catalyst to initiate new dialogues around immigration
WASHINGTON, May 17, 2011 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- At a time when many U.S. cities and towns are exploding with tension around immigration related issues, Welcome to Shelbyville, a new documentary about how residents in a small Tennessee town have worked to understand, challenge, and accept new immigrants in their community, will air nationwide on the Emmy Award-winning PBS Series Independent Lens on May 24, 2011. Featured prominently in the film are the efforts of the Tennessee affiliate of the new nonprofit Welcoming America, a national organization whose focus is now on replicating this template for success in cities and towns across the country.
Set against the backdrop of a shaky economy during the 2008 Presidential election, Welcome to Shelbyville takes an intimate look at a southern town as its residents - comprised of Whites, African-Americans, Latinos and Somalis - grapple with their beliefs, their histories and their evolving ways of life. The film focuses on the work of Welcoming Tennessee, an affiliate of Welcoming America, as its local partners in Shelbyville, TN, struggle to build a more welcoming community in their town amid growing hostilities.
The film Welcome to Shelbyville was directed and produced by Kim A. Snyder and executive produced by BeCause Foundation in association with Active Voice. It is a recipient of a 2010 Gucci-Tribeca Documentary Fund grant and an official selection of the U.S. State Department's 2010 American Documentary Showcase.
"My own perspective is simply that immigrant integration is not always easy, and that a more nuanced national dialogue needs to be taking place, perhaps taking cues from folks like the ones in Shelbyville with less of an eye on political correctness and with no particular political agenda other than that of living more harmoniously with their neighbors," said director and producer Kim A. Snyder, who spent over a year filming the documentary in Shelbyville, Tennessee.
In the weeks leading up to the PBS premiere, Kim A. Snyder and Welcoming America have been meeting with affiliate groups and city officials across the country and participating in a series of film screenings and panel discussions highlighting the significance of the film as a tool for meaningful social change, as well as the efforts of the group to replicate the success of Shelbyville in 14 other states.
"The film is a powerful portrayal of the impact that immigration is currently having on our neighborhoods and communities," stated David Lubell, Executive Director, Welcoming America. "In the midst of increasingly heated rhetoric around this issue, it is a shining example of how Americans can unite to ensure that the newest members of our communities are fully incorporated into the very fabric of our society. As we see it, working together benefits everyone, both new and old alike."
Welcoming America is organized around the principal that Americans are empathetic and compassionate people, and that this compassion is often clouded by the country's increasingly divisive immigration debate. By uniting local leaders across sectors and sharing the stories of residents of all backgrounds, the Welcoming America model is working to reduce fear of immigration and promote acceptance in communities across the country.
Welcoming America is a national, grassroots-driven collaborative that works to promote mutual respect and cooperation between foreign-born and U.S.-born Americans. www.welcomingamerica.org.
Kim A. Snyder is an award-winning filmmaker whose most recent film, Welcome to Shelbyville, is recipient of a Gucci-Tribeca Documentary Fund grant, a selection of the U.S. State Department's 2010 American Documentary Showcase, and will air on PBS's Independent Lens in early 2011. For more information on Welcome to Shelbyville, visit www.pbs.org/welcome-to-shelbyville.
BeCause Foundation ignites social change through the powerful fusion of documentary filmmaking and creative outreach and engagement projects. www.becausefoundation.org
Active Voice uses film, television and multimedia to put a human face on the issues of our times. www.activevoice.net
SOURCE Welcoming America
Related: Welcome to Shelbyville, Events
By David Waters
Saturday, May 14, 2011
SHELBYVILLE, Tenn. -- Luci Taylor first noticed the change when she was working at Walmart and women wearing long, flowing robes and head scarves began shopping there.
"They were fascinating. They looked like Catholic nuns running around," said Taylor, a Catholic who moved here from Ohio more than 25 years ago.
Stephen Caine noticed when his son came home from school one day and mentioned that he was working on a project with Eprah and Muhammad.
"Not your typical Middle Tennessee names," said Caine, the pastor of First Presbyterian Church who moved here from South Carolina in 2000.
Welcome to Shelbyville, whose bucolic hills and valleys are home to the Sharpie marker, the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration -- and scores of Somali Muslim refugees who have resettled here, mostly to work at the Tyson Foods poultry processing plant.
In recent years, faith-based organizations such as Catholic Charities and World Vision, working with the U.S. State Department, have resettled an estimated 1,000 Somali refugees among Bedford County's 45,000 residents.
The Somali resettlement has been unsettling for a rural area already experiencing a growing Latino population.
Shelbyville "is in many ways a microcosm of many rural communities across the country that are grappling with the challenges of rapid demographic growth and integration," filmmaker Kim Snyder said in a recent interview.
Snyder explores Shelbyville's efforts to understand and accept its new Muslim neighbors in her documentary "Welcome to Shelbyville," which PBS will broadcast later this month. WKNO2 will show the film at 9 p.m. May 29, but the local PBS station is co-hosting a free screening at 5 and 7 p.m. Tuesday at Malco's Studio on the Square.
Shelbyville isn't the only Middle Tennessee community grappling with Islam.
In 2008, a mosque in Columbia was burned. Attempts to build new mosques in Brentwood and Antioch have been stopped. Opponents of a new mosque in Murfreesboro have staged protests against it and gone to court to try to stop it.
Last year, failed Republican congressional candidate Lou Ann Zelenik called the Murfreesboro mosque part of "a political movement designed to fracture the moral and political foundation of Middle Tennessee."
Earlier this year, two Middle Tennessee legislators introduced a bill that would have made it a felony to follow Islamic teachings, including praying, fasting and almsgiving -- all part of Shariah or sacred Islamic law.
The bill has been amended to remove all references to Islam, but as Dr. Gary Gunderson of Methodist Le Bonheur Healthcare points out in a guest column in this section today, the bill still carries an anti-Islam bias.
Shelbyville hasn't avoided anti-Muslim sentiment, but Snyder thinks the community has responded with more hospitality than most because people of faith like Taylor and Caine have worked to welcome and get to know their new neighbors.
Taylor, who is giving the new immigrants lessons in speaking English and being Southern, said much of the anxiety about the Somalis is the product of a culture gap.
"A lot of people here think the Somalis are being unfriendly or even rude," Taylor said. "They don't look at you or speak to you in the grocery store. They don't shake hands or hug. But in Somalia, Muslim women are taught not to do those things as a sign of humility and respect. We like to hug, but they don't even hug other women."
In the film, Taylor, a third-generation Mexican-American, hosts a Thanksgiving dinner for several of her new neighbors.
"God has blessed me in so many ways, but I have felt what it's like to be an outsider, to have people judge you because of how you look or talk or practice your faith," she said. "Most of us are from somewhere else, and most of us came here for freedom -- just like the Somalis."
Caine said suspicions surrounding the Somalis also are a product of anti-Muslim rhetoric and distorted views of Islam.
"When you've got a top state official calling Islam a violent cult, it doesn't put people in a very welcoming mood," Caine said. He was referring to Lt. Gov. Ron Ramsey, who last year said, "You could even argue whether being a Muslim is actually a religion, or is it a nationality, a way of life or cult."
Caine, who is shown in the film meeting and talking with the local imam, has taken some flak for his efforts to welcome Muslims to Shelbyville. He expects to hear more criticism after PBS broadcasts the documentary.
"I'm just reading the Bible and doing what it tells me to do," said Caine. "Welcome the stranger. Love your neighbor. Do for the least of these. It's not that hard."
Some Shelbyville residents think their community has been asked to absorb too many immigrants.
In fact, the legislature this week approved a bill by state Sen. Jim Tracy, a Shelbyville Republican, to allow communities that lack "sufficient absorptive capacity" to opt out of refugee resettlement programs.
Caine sees another option.
"Our small community is changing each and every day and we can either resist it or embrace it," he said.
"We can wall ourselves off, become defensive and rigid and hardhearted. We can exclude those not like us, who don't look, sound, speak and worship like us. Or we can listen to the word of God and through our faith embrace the stranger and learn from them and them from us."
Related: Welcome to Shelbyville, Events
Related: Welcome to Shelbyville, Immigration, Upcoming Films
Read the entire article 'The Bully Project': A Film Takes on Harassment, From Iowa to Tribeca"There are a number of things that are going to come together that are really exciting around The Bully Project. I would like to think that we are maybe at the beginning of a tipping-point moment, and that hopefully The Bully Project will be a piece of that and give something really tangible that people can hold on to and run with and feel moved through and then translate that into action."
Related: Bullying, Upcoming Films
In 2002, shortly before the Iowa caucuses, billboards began popping up in small towns across the state. The signs, featuring archival photos of German, Scandinavian and Eastern European immigrants -- all of whom had emigrated in numbers to the state in past generations -- read: "Welcome the Immigrant You Once Were."
The billboards were part of a statewide effort to influence the discussion on immigration, according to Devin Burghart, Vice President of the Institute for Research & Education on Human Rights and one of the campaign's organizers. "We saw efforts to toxify the climate, to make it less hospitable to new immigrants into the state," he says. "We knew where things were going [on immigration], but we had a hard time convincing people that it was going to get as nasty as it did."
The current tenor of the immigration debate makes 2002 -- a time when Jan Brewer was still largely unknown to the American public -- look like the Golden Age of Tolerance.
But, even though the tone of the national debate has heated up, communities in several states across the country are coming together to address the anxiety and fear surrounding immigration in a bid to strengthen ties between foreign born and native residents.
Born out of those first billboards in Iowa, the effort coalesced into a national group called Welcoming America in 2007. Four years later, the movement is currently operating in 15 states: from Birmingham, Alabama to Crete, Nebraska to Yamhill County, Oregon.
Along with billboards, there are now posters, radio ads, and television PSAs extolling welcoming messages. Complementing these efforts are dances, potlucks and picnics convened by local "Welcoming Committees" and held in partnership with Rotary clubs, church groups and civic organizations, all in an effort to forge stronger, more integrated communities.
Watch a clip of Welcoming America's PSA in North Carolina:
Listen to one of the organization's radio ads here:
Though this effort remains distinctly grassroots, Welcoming America now counts blue chip philanthropist George Soros as one of its biggest supporters -- hisOpen Society Institute granted $150,000 to the organization in December of 2010.
Raquiba LaBrie, the program director for OSI's Equality and Opportunity Fund, says of Welcoming America, "We thought this was a powerful model for reducing anxiety and undermining prejudice about immigrants and refugees through old school methods," specifically, person to person contact.
OSI is not the only organization noticing Welcoming America's efforts. Two weeks ago, the Draper Richards Kaplan Foundation, established in part by venture capital guru William Draper, awarded a $300,000 "entrepreneur" grant to the organization's executive director, David Lubell. And, on May 24, PBS will nationally broadcast a documentary about the program called "Welcome to Shelbyville."
Anne Marie Burgoyne, the portfolio director for Draper Richards Kaplan, believes Welcoming America is implementing a model that could change the way immigration is discussed on a national level. "We make general operation grants to innovative organizations to help take them to scale," she says. "We only fund things we think will have a high impact."
According to Lubell, what sets his project apart from other immigration-focused initiatives is its focus on resident populations, rather than just immigrant communities -- which tend to be the traditional focus of outreach efforts, including English language programs and jobs training. "A lot of groups are trying to water the seed, and not the soil surrounding it," says Lubell. "We're trying to water the soil. Nothing's going to grow just by watering one alone."
Suzette Brooks-Masters, who oversees immigration-related grantmaking at the J.M. Kaplan Fund, which put $90,000 towards Welcoming America activities in 2010, explains, "What I really liked about Welcoming America was that it was addressing a problem that a lot of philanthropists and a lot of advocacy groups had not tackled. Namely, how you talk to mainstream America" about immigration?
She adds, "A lot of energy has been put into the immigrant rights movement, creating infrastructure for that movement, building power -- which is all incredibly legitimate -- but the problem is it that it doesn't actually address how to talk to native Americans."
According to Lubell, one of the reasons his group is able to reach these resident populations is because Welcoming America events and communication efforts avoid any discussion of immigration reform or politics. "We don't advocate for policy,"he says. "We're a community building organization."
By avoiding the specifics of reform -- and instead focusing on the social and cultural fears surrounding immigration and changing communities -- Lubell says he is able to speak to what Brooks-Masters calls "the 60 percent in the middle."
According to Lubell, "Our main goal is to reach those people who are unsure whether immigration growth is a positive thing or not. And some of them are very reasonable -- they're just not getting accurate information about immigration."
So far, it remains difficult to assess how effective the organization's efforts have been -- especially as communities across the country continue to push forward with divisive legislation, including controversial English-only laws.
While Lubell is making a concerted effort to analyze his organization's efficacy (Welcoming America is set to begin pre- and post-event surveys for certain participants later this year) the relatively small scale of the efforts thus far and the inherently intangible nature of assessing public opinion -- as opposed to, say, measuring poverty rates or test scores -- makes such analysis difficult.
In 2010, for example, Lubell estimates that Welcoming America has targeted 8,611,247 individuals in the communities where initiatives (including communications and public events) have taken place. Of this group, the organization estimates it reached 736,185 immigrants - or 10% of the total audience.
Both Lubell and his foundational supporters say person-to person contact is creating more resilient communities. "The events," Lubell says, "are the most transformative." And while the organization contends that community dialogues and presentations are the best opportunity to change perceptions about immigration and fuel a strong "ripple effect", others question whether attendees of the local mixers aren't already inclined to have a favorable, or at least a considerably more progressive, view of immigrants.
Suzanne Donato, a professor of Sociology at Vanderbilt University in Tennessee, where Welcoming America has launched several initiatives, says that those "conversations can overwhelmingly feature an audience that feels the same way." In Donato's mind, Welcoming America is most successful in reaching that elusive 60% via its media and communications efforts.
"Those billboards were very dramatic," she says, referring to signs that were erected in Tennessee in 2006. "They certainly got peoples' attention -- everyone who drove down Interstate 40. Many different kinds of people saw them. And then there were letters to the editor [that followed]: ones that were pro-immigrant, some were anti, some were in the middle. But the billboards initiated conversations."
Donato also underscores the effectiveness of Welcoming America's targeted outreach programs: "They send people out to have conversations with people who, in the local paper or in the news, have said things that might have been considered unwelcoming to immigrants. Or that suggested the person saying them was smart, but may not have understood the full immigration story."
These outreach efforts, Donato contends, reach local officials: county commissioners, district attorneys and some law enforcement members -- providing a considerable ripple effect in small towns and cities.
Another issue complicating Welcoming America's mission is the fact that many of its local organizers are also independently involved in immigration advocacy efforts. Darcy Tromanhauser, a Nebraska coordinator for the Welcoming America activities, is also the director of the Immigrant Integration & Civic Participation Program at the advocacy group Nebraska Appleseed. Speaking to this potential conflict, Tromanhauser says, "I think those sorts of dividing lines happen all the time. For example, at a non-profit we can't do any partisan political activities. People are used to that in this space."
Convincing resident populations that Welcoming America is not part of any pro-immigration advocacy or policy efforts can be tricky even when the local representatives are completely independent. Kristin Collins, who runs Uniting North Carolina, Welcoming America's local affiliate in the state, notes that, "We're the only organization that operates as an independent non-profit, not affiliated with any advocacy groups. But our message is pro-immigrant -- so people tend to think, 'Oh they're just another one of those immigration advocacy groups.' We're really trying to show people that we're different. We're working hard to go to places where there's a mixed crowd with various beliefs and political positions."
Welcoming America organizers insist that they are trying to reach these disparate voices, but the organization has yet to make inroads in some of the battleground states where the immigration debate is at its fiercest, including Arizona, New Mexico and Nevada.
Of Arizona, Lubell says: "It's a place that we'll get to, but our organizations are still getting their feet wet and learning how this all works." Going to the state now, he contends, would be akin to "going straight to a senior high school AP class while you're still in junior high."
And while critics are certain to measure Welcoming America's work against the strength of conservative efforts -- the passage of laws requiring immigration status checks, or continued debate over the 14th Amendment, for example -- combatting the hardliners isn't really part of the organization's mission. "Some people are never going to be persuaded that this country needs to have fair immigration policies," says Raquiba LaBrie of OSI. "And I don't suggest they waste time trying to."
Some foundational supporters may have their own internally articulated goals inextricably tied to broader immigration policy reform, but Lubell remains defiant in his belief that reaching the moderate center and building stronger communities is the focus of his efforts. Regardless of the ultimate outcome, it's undeniable that Welcoming America exists as a haven from the otherwise heated rhetoric emanating from both sides of the aisle.
In explaining why he does what he does, Lubell recalls a personal anecdote: "I switched high schools when I was younger, and there were those students who were really welcoming to me, who gave me a good orientation -- and as a result I really succeeded in that school. I became head of the community service program, which got me headed in the direction I'm in today. It's similar with immigrants and the people who want to make communities stronger. When you feel more welcome, you succeed."
Related: Welcome to Shelbyville, Immigration
Related: Welcome to Shelbyville, Immigration
First Posted: 04/14/11 12:54 PM ET Updated: 04/14/11 03:50 PM ET